Which one is White Antelope?

Although fans of Colorado history have probably heard of the most significant Native American leaders — Black Kettle, Left Hand, White Antelope, One Eye, and so on — portraits from the era are frustratingly undocumented. It would be nice to be able to point at a particular picture and say with certainty that this fellow is White Antelope and that fellow is Neva, but it hasn’t happened so far and probably never will.

Case in point: Two important portraits were taken in the fall of 1864 of the “peace chiefs” who had come to Denver to talk peace with Chivington and Evans (fruitlessly, as it turned out). A stenographer was present at this session, so we know at least the following chiefs were present: Black Kettle, White Antelope, Bull Bear. We know Left Hand wasn’t there, and there’s no mention of One Eye being there.

Here’s the most famous portrait taken, focusing just on the fellows in the middle row:

Image

Now, here’s how Colorado historians and authors identify these men:

Denver Public Library Western History: l. to rt.: 1. Neva (Arapaho), 2. Bull Bear (Cheyenne), 3. Black Kettle (Cheyenne), 4. One Eye (Cheyenne), 5. unidentified.

Hoig, The Sand Creek Massacre:  l to r 1. White Antelope. 2. Neva. 3. Black Kettle. 4. Bull Bear. 5. unidentified.

Hoig, Peace Chiefs of the Cheyenne: l to r 1. White Antelope. 2. Bull Bear. 3. Black Kettle. 4. unidentified. 5. unidentified.

Ubbelohde/Benson/Smith, A Colorado History: Identifies Black Kettle and leaves the rest blank

Coel, Chief Left Hand: l to r. 1. White Antelope, 2. Bull Bear 3. Black Kettle, 4. Neva 5. No-ta-nee

Michno, Encyclopedia of Indian Wars:  l to rt: 1. (left blank) 2. Bull Bear 3. Black Kettle. 4. Neva 5. White Antelope.

At Camp Weld, a second portrait was taken, the central figures shown below:

Image

Here’s how Coel and Hoig identify them: .

Coel: seated l to rt. Neva, Black Kettle, Bull Bear, White Antelope.

Hoig: seated l to rt. Bull Bear, Black Kettle, Neva, White Antelope.

As you can see, there are a few consistencies (we know which one is Black Kettle anyway), but there is plenty of confusion as to who is who in the remaining cast of characters. It’s a pity, because these men played a critical role in Colorado history.

Cheyenne Chief One-Eye is a particular case in point. In the Denver Public Library historical photographs collection is a hand-drawn portrait of Chief One-Eye. If you examine the portrait, however, you’ll notice that the artist took certain liberties in creating the picture. It was obviously copied from the Camp Weld portrait –one of the above photographs — not drawn while Chief One Eye (killed at Sand Creek) was sitting for the artist. Furthermore, the “model” for the portrait was either Neva or Bull bear, depending on whom you ask:

Image

One suspects that the artist decided this was One-Eye because one of the man’s eyes looks slightly off. However, One Eye is never quoted in the transcript, whereas he spoke at great length at an earlier council (the Smoky Hill council).

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Which one is White Antelope?

  1. I’m fascinated that the main chiefs are misidentified! Consistently. I’m finding the same problem in the Utes. Ouray is identified as Colorow; Colorow is identified as Ouray, and Ouray has enough brothers to populate the entire state! I am working through the Utes and think I just found an old photo of Ouray and his true brother, Quenche, taken in 1868, totally unidentifed except “Ute brothers or friends.”

  2. This is a couple years late, but for anyone who may be attempting to identify specific Ute Indians, the book “Utes; The Mountain People” by Jan Pettit–recommended to me by a Ute Mountain Ute Tribal member–has many historical photos which identify the people in the pictures. Some of the “clearest” pics are on pages 146-147, and there’s also a brief “Glossary of Names” in the back, nine of which have pictures with them. It’s an excellent book with historically accurate information, and I highly recommend it for anyone who’s interested in Ute history. [Included in the book is a picture of Ouray and Chipeta which was taken at the same time as the one you link above, except Ouray is standing in the one in the book. Those pictures were taken on a trip Ouray and Chepita made to Washington immediately following the conclusion of the Meeker “Massacre,” White River Ute Commission Investigation in Colorado. In August of the same year, 1880, just a few months after the conclusion of the Congressional investigation into the Meeker “Massacre” in D.C., at which both Ouray and Chepita testified, Ouray died.]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s